Skip to main content
See those intricate Lego creations? This boy has no trouble concentrating.

See those intricate Lego creations? This boy has no trouble concentrating.


“But I hate school!  I’ll never go back!”

His tears were copious. He was weeping.  Weeping.  Christmas vacation was on its last legs.  School resumed in three days and my eight-year old son was inconsolable.

He has a powerful imagination, and it was hurting him – imagining his return to school – so I asked him what his ideal school would be, if he were in charge.

“There would be no school!” he cried.

Hm.  Not the direction I’d hoped for.  I persisted.  “But that’s cheating,” I said. “In this game you think of how to make it great, not go away.”

“The only great school is no school!  I want to be home schooled!”

I winced.  There it was, the demand I dreaded. Home school.  My best friend and many others of my friends homeschool and I think they’re amazing!  I think it’s ideal if you can do it.  But me?  No, it’s not for me.  I’ve said so countless times to my husband, my friends, my kids, and to strangers who don’t even ask.  I want to do my work, and I need them at school in order to do it.

I walked away from my sobbing child. Maybe he would calm down if he had no audience.

Ten minutes later. . .  No. Still crying.  Inside, I cried, too.  But my cries were more for myself than compassion for his pain.  I do not want to home school!  I need him to go to school!

My mind flashed back to when he was an infant.  He was the sweetest baby.  He slept, he ate, he played and smiled, and then he slept some more.  He never cried!  Well, except when we were in the car.  When he was strapped into his hard plastic car seat and facing away from me in the back seat for indefinite periods of time, he would wail.  And I would let him.  I had places to go!  He needed to get used to it! I couldn’t put my entire life on hold for him, could I?  It wasn’t until my best friend came for a visit and was distressed by his wailing that I realized how much I had hardened my heart to his cries when they were inconvenient.  “Shouldn’t we at least stop the car?” she said.  “What’s the hurry anyway?”

I look at him now, eight years old and curled in the fetal position on my bed – mine, not his own – with fresh eyes.  He is the sweetest boy.  He is playful, imaginative and bright.  He makes us laugh and is good company.  He used to be more easy going, though.  He started to be more emotional and prone to anger around four.  It occurs to me that that’s about the time he started his first all-day school.  He enjoyed nursery school and Kindergarten well enough, but since first grade he has found it hard to concentrate and get his worksheets done on time. Don’t get him started on homework! He has been asking to be home schooled for at least a year now, but I have resisted. I believe I need him to go to school.

Oh. I hear it now: I need him to go to school.  Is it true?  I ask myself the first question of The Work of Byron Katie, the method of questioning painful thoughts.  It is, to me, a miraculous method.  I use it whenever I notice that I’m believing a thought that is causing me pain; in other words, every day.  She and many other spiritual teachers teach that it’s our thoughts about our circumstances that cause us pain, not the circumstances themselves.  Reality is always kinder, she says, than our thoughts about it.

So: Capture the thought and question it.  Is it true that I need him to go to school?  Can I be absolutely certain that I need him to be in school?  No.  I can’t be absolutely certain.  If I can’t be absolutely certain that I’m right about that, then the possibility that he is right – that he actually should be home – opens up.  I remember other times – there are so many! – that he and his sister have taught me things. The times I resisted what they wanted or needed, then gave in out of exhaustion and found that they led us to a sweeter spot than I could have imagined!

How do I react when I believe the thought (that I need him to be in school and he desperately wants to be home)?  Well, I fight him. I harden my heart. I am the hard plastic car seat that faces his soft little body away from everything he loves (me).  Shouldn’t we at least stop the car? What’s the hurry anyway? 

Who would I be without the thought? Open. Curious. Soft. I would stop the car, stop driving to a destination, which I believe is Best and Important, and listen to what he is telling me.

Turn the thought around.  I don’t need him to go to school.  I need him to be home.  Could those turnarounds be as true or truer than my original, painful thoughts?  Well, for starters, they feel good when I say them.  My body feels looser and lighter.  It isn’t until I feel the physical and psychic freedom of this turnaround that I notice how violently I had been resisting!

I need me to go to school.  Maybe having him home would teach me something I need to learn.  I have been consciously resisting this for so many years.  In all those years of resistance and having both my children in school so that I could work unfettered, the business that I was sure I’d build just. . . hasn’t happened.  I have not built it yet.  Could it be that dropping my resistance to having them home and incorporating them into my work life could shift something?  Could leaning into home schooling create not just happier kids but a more robust professional life for myself?

Softened to the point of porousness from The Work, I curl my soft body around his and we fall asleep together.  I wake up lighthearted and unafraid.  I hadn’t realized I was afraid, but the absence of it is noticeable.  It is proof that I’m on to something good.

He doesn’t mention his dread of school again until the night before school resumes.  I haven’t told him of my new openness to home schooling or my decision to work the month of January as if I’m already homeschooling.  I want to prove to myself that I can be more productive in less time.  I say nothing, yet he seems to feel that something is different, because he does not cry.  He is nervous but no longer desperate.

“I don’t want to go back tomorrow,” he says Sunday night.

I say, “Is there some way we can make it better?  Maybe a special breakfast or special lunch? Or we could plan some fun for after school?” I notice I’m curious about what he’ll say, no longer needing a particular answer or speedy closure.

“Will you wake me up early so there’s time to play before school?” he suggests.

“I’d be delighted to! What a neat idea,” I reply, and I mean it.

“And would you consider maybe possibly letting me have Wednesdays off from school?” he ventures. Wednesdays are short days.

“I think I’d like that,” I reply, and I mean it.

He smiles then is thoughtful.  “Well, maybe just every three weeks,” he says.  “We don’t want to go crazy.”

We both smile and start laughing.  We hug each other and he gives me a dozen kisses.  Will I home school?  Maybe.  I don’t want to go crazy!  Dropping my resistance to it, though, is the first step on a journey toward something better than I previously imagined.  Of that I’m sure.

Do you home school?  If not, have you ever been tempted — or begged?  What did you do? Do you have an experience with finding exciting possibilities after dropping resistance? Please comment below!

Join the discussion 5 Comments

  • Kimberly B. says:

    Oh Allison! I was holding my breath thoughout this whole post! 🙂

    I am sorry that there has been struggle over this, but I completely understand your feelings – especially the fear. I won’t feel like I’m really jumping into homeschooling until the first day of Kindergarten starts and I keep Ila home. But even though I know homeschooling is where my heart lies at the moment, I still have fears of the commitment I’m making. At those times, I also question my thoughts and though I don’t come up with any perfect answers, I DO feel the fear leave for a while. It’s a wonderful lightness, isn’t it?

    I hope you find the right rhythm for your family and that you all have peace very soon. Good luck!


    • allison says:

      I was hoping you’d see this, Kimberly! 🙂

      As with everything, we can only ever take it one day at a time, right? We keep listening. We keep trusting. The next step presents itself!

      Thank you!

  • Fran says:

    Homeschooling is a joy. I have four boys under the age of 8. I homeschool 3 of them. It is always a challenge…a juggling act of sorts. Even as I homeschool my children I have the same thoughts as you… though I am reminded, daily, why I continue. My children get to explore their creativity, their interests, and have all their questions answered. Being homeschooled also gives them an additional sense of purpose. I need them. I need their help to make our household run. We need eachother.

    • allison says:

      Thank you for sharing, Fran! I’m encouraged by your experience. I am inspired, too, when you talk of your children having a sense of purpose, of feeling like an integral part of the family. That is so important to me!

  • “Softened to the point of porousness” this is what I believe parenting does to us…even as many times as I’ve hardened my heart, like a plastic car seat.

    Children get through.

    This is the joy, the spiritual path of parenting, because my children have gotten me to do things I’d NEVER have done without them. Namely: sit in silence for hours, shoot a bow, pick up a snake and hold my breath across the pool.

    If you told me when they were growing in my belly I’d be doing those things I’d have laughed. Me? nope. Not gonna happen. Then Love intervenes. That soft, powerful Love that turns the world upside down.

    Of course that Love has the power to show you how to invite more business into your life while you’re “learning how to teach.”

    This is a powerful post, full of the wisdom of following and surrender. I believe in you and I believe in the love between you and your children.

Leave a Reply